Nathan Bransford | Writing, Book Editing, Publishing

Helping writers achieve their dreams!

Subscribe to the blog!

Receive the blog directly in your inbox when there are new posts!

Reader Interactions

Comments

  4. Definitely Voldemort. We know who he is even when we do not speak his name. Because, after all, He Who Must Not Be Named did great things–terrible, yes, but great.

    Goodness I'm Harry Potter deprived.

    Reply

  5. Heathcliff in Wuthering Heights. I'm pretty sure he's not supposed to be a villain but no other character has ever sent chills up my spine like he does. Pure selfishness in a violent, manipulative shell. What havok did he play in such insidious ways!

    Reply

  6. Eleanor Shaw Iselin from Richard Condon's The Manchurian Candidate is just about the most cold-blooded character I've ever read.

    What she does to her own son, and what she allows to happen to him, is monstrous and unforgiveable.

    I guess that doesn't make her the greatest—just the worst, sorry . . .

    Reply

  7. The Grand High Witch in Roald Dahl's The Witches used to give me nightmares…then again, so did too much of Mom's attempt at green bean casserole.

    Reply

  8. DOUBLE RAINBOWS are the greatest villains of all time.

    they have been known to make FULL GROWN MEN WEEP and question everything they've ever known.

    also ahab is kind of legit.

    Reply

  9. I have a love/hate relationship with Gretchen from Chelsea Cain's thrillers. She's like the female version of Hannibal, and in some ways, deadlier.

    Reply

  10. Wow, green bean casserole as the greatest villain!

    Christopher Walken played such a psychologically evil guy that I couldn't watch him in another movie for many years until I learned that he dances.

    The Borg were pretty bad too.

    Villains that start with The.

    (i.e., The Devil.)

    Anyone or thing that could take someone's humanity or loved one is the most evil to me.

    One of the worst villains is drugs.

    Reply

  12. Probably not your typical villain, but there is no character I hated more by the end of a book than Mrs. Bennet in Pride and Prejudice. Not so much evil as really stupid (which is its own evil, isn't it?).

    Reply

  13. Mrs. Danvers from Rebecca was definitely creepy. Also, the White Witch from Narnia was pure evil, and even scarier when I saw her on the big screen.

    Reply

  15. Simon Legree is the greatest villian in fiction. In fact he was so dispicable that his brutality was partially credited with starting the American Civil War.

    Reply

  16. I would have to say It is the greatest villain–both in Madeleine L'Engle's A Wrinkle In Time (the book that got me addicted to sci-fi/fantasy) and in Stephen King's It (that scared the bejeezus out of me.)

    Reply

  17. Oh no Nathan – Bill Sykes is far more the villain than Fagin!

    For me, greatest villain has to come from my greatest novel so it's Alec d'Urberville – Tess of the d'Urbevilles.

    Reply

  18. When I saw Iago, I immediately thought, "The parrot from Aladdin? He wasn't that bad!"

    I needs to brush up on me Shakespeare.

    Greatest Villain in Fiction goes to:
    Dolores Umbridge, HP:Order of the Phoenix

    No one character ever got under my skin more than she did. Sure Voldemort is trying to kill everyone and take over the world, blah, blah, blah.

    But Umbridge's sadism, sense of propriety and the insufferable decor of her office (so much pink!) just made me squirm.

    Stephen King agrees, as he "noted the success of any novel is due to a great villain, with Umbridge as the "greatest make-believe villain to come along since Hannibal Lecter…".

    Reply

  19. I like Mr. Croup and Mr. Vandemar from Neverwhere. They're totally evil, but also more than a little odd. It makes a change from bland evil.

    Reply

  20. Its a toss up between Hannibal Lector and Annie Wilkes (Misery).

    But then again, there is always Satan from Paradise Lost (Milton)

    Reply

  22. humbert humbert.

    i find him truly evil because he makes you feel bad for him, you actually sympathize with his cause, despicable.

    ms. danvers is a great one too.

    Reply

  23. Voldemort, definitely. I may be biased toward all things Harry Potter, but Voldemort has so much more dimension than any other villain. Throughout the series we see that he is more than "evil for evil's sake" but there was a process to his evil. It's a human transformation. Hannibal isn't a bad choice for this reason either, but I prefer Voldy.

    Reply

  24. lestI teach British literature and every semester my students say they hate Gertrude (from Hamlet) more than any other character they have ever read. This could be because more watch the movie than read the play and are completely grossed out when she makes out with her son, but for whatever resaon, they absolutely LOATHE her…

    Reply

  26. I think the society in Unwind is one of the best villains, if you want to expand the definition of villains. So frightening because it wasn't just one person doing evil acts, it was the WHOLE society supporting them.

    Also, honest Iago is awesomely bad.

    Reply

  27. no doubt it has to be, from the books that i've read, annie wilkes from stephen king's misery. she literally had me squirming at night thinking about her pure sadistic evil. eeeee. then there was mrs. danvers of rebecca. she sent chills up my spine in the scene where she's chiding the MC into jumping from the window.
    two other good ones are voldemort, of course, and umbridge.

    Reply

  29. A great villain to me requires three things:

    1. They threaten you mentally, not physically. A physical threat is a lot easier to deal with, it's tangible, you can respond to it. A mental threat… not so much.

    2. They believe they're right or justified.

    3. They do things their own way. It's one thing to be threatened with death by a serial killer, another to be threatened by being eaten.

    And with that, I'd put Pennywise from Stephen King's IT near the top of the list.

    1. He becomes whatever you fear. Afraid of werewolves, he becomes a werewolf. He doesn't just want to kill you physically, he wants to terrify you mentally. 'Cause you taste better. No better evidence of this than the suicide that occurs when one of the characters learns he has to go back to face It.

    2. He needs to feed. If he doesn't eat, he'll die. From his perspective, it's black and white. You have to die so that he can live. And centuries of doing this have messed with his head a little.

    3. He doesn't just kill children, he kills them by being what they fear the most.

    And come on. He's a CLOWN.

    Those things are creepy to begin with.

    Reply

  30. I've never really read anything recently with a tangible villain… but since this is fiction, then I'm at least mentioning Azazel — The Yellow-Eyed Demon. He's pure evil. He's in it all for himself, and he doesn't care who dies in the process. Top that with a great sense of humor and a personality like Jack Nicholson, and you've got yourself a great villain.

    Reply

  31. Well, I know he's from a movie, but the SS Colonel Hans Landa deserves a mention here.

    I'm not sure I'm qualified for this, though. I always end up rooting for villains, no matter how bad.

    Reply

  35. Cancer

    Brings the meanest baddest son of bitches to their knees.

    and

    The hunter who shot Bambi's mom. I still get nightmares. I think he died of triggerfingerdeckaphobia.

    Reply

  38. I'm going to interpret best as most interesting and vote for Ahab from Moby Dick. I mean, the guy basically wants to symbolically kill God. That's pretty messed up and oh so compelling to read (at least during the interesting parts of that massive tome).

    Reply

  40. Oh goodness, how am I supposed to pick the GREATEST? Satan in PARADISE LOST(and most Satan analogies, such as the White Witch in The Chronicles of Narnia). The priest in THE HUNCHBACK OF NOTRE DAME. I thought Broud in THE CLAN OF THE CAVE BEAR was pretty brutal. What about Big Brother in 1984? Can we count things like that? Or characters like Briony from ATONEMENT? I sometimes think these characters are more interesting than the straight-up "I'm evil!" guys, but they seem more insidious because they aren't so obvious. I'm not sure they count as villains for our purpose, though.

    Reply

  41. Erasmus OR Omnius from the DUNE novels by Frank Herbert.

    Two major characters which are 'thinking machine' robots, with Erasmus effectively igniting the Machine jihad because of his actions. Truly evil is this one, as all humans are fodder for his experiments.

    One word names seem to emphasize importance, or individualism, and in some cases, are intended to evoke fear, anxiety, etc.

    Great question and I'm sure there will be a lot of different bad guys showing up in the comments to this post. Human and otherwise.

    Reply

  42. The Alien Entity in Arthur C. Clarke's Childhood's End. You don't know what it is, where it came from or what's going to happen when it absorbs the earth, but in the meantime it's turning all the children into telekinetic zombies. I love Clarke, but I wanted to vomit when I finished reading that book. Literally, it went right to my stomach and I felt ill for several days.

    Reply

  43. Dolores Umbridge from Harry Potter drove me crazy. She was sadistic with a sugar-coated voice; she used other's weaknesses against them and enjoyed laughing at them; she thought she was always right. But you know what was creepiest about Umbridge to me? She liked kitties. It just did NOT fit with her personality. And she had waaayyyy too many.

    Reply

  44. Mrs. Danvers, definitely. We saw an English television production of REBECCA some years ago with Diana Rigg as Mrs. Danvers and all I have to do is say that name to make my daughter shudder. 🙂

    Reply

  45. It's not literary, but my favorite villain of all time is Rotti Largo, from Repo: The Genetic Opera. He's got his reasons, he's got a plan, he makes a promise and he never breaks it. Respectable and evil, all rolled up into one.

    Reply

  48. @E. A. Provost: Arthur C. Clarke's Childhood's End was the first sci-fi book I read, the one that started me reading every sci-fi book I could find.

    Different impressions for different tastes, I suppose. Perhaps the age that we read these books could result in a variety of impressions.

    Reply

  50. I have to agree with many of the posters here that King, L'Engle, Shakespeare and Rowling do a wonderful job of bringing some of the best villians to print, theater and the movies.

    But don't forget Clive Barker, HP Lovecraft, Alfred Hitchcock or Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and Robert Louis Stevenson. I am just glad that literature filled with so many "good" bad guys. What would these books be without a strong villian? What would The Stand be without Flagg or Othello be without Iago?

    I shudder to think…

    Reply

  53. The ones that really get me are the ones that aren't fantasy books, but real-to-life books that involve mental/physical/sexual abuse and/or torture, especially of children.

    Umbridge is very well-written. But the really horrifying ones – the parents in Push (the movie Precious) or the mother/grandmother duo in Flowers in the Attic. Long-term abuse over time. I'm sure there are many, many more, but I try not to read those types of books, frankly. They totally get under my skin and freak me out.

    Reply

  54. As the enemy of both good and evil, Death is the greatest villain in fiction. Good people die too young and bad people live too long. In the end, death is the unknown, uncontrollable element of humanity that's inevitability is the enemy or ally of everyone.

    Reply

  56. Voldemort, Umbridge, Sauron…great villains all. However, the one that has outshined and outlasted all of them in my memory is Leland Gaunt from Stephen King's Needful Things. He was so subtly insidious. Fantastic.

    Reply

  57. I actually agree with Dolores Umbridge, except for the fact that she was so soundly beaten, without ever being as effective as Voldemort … but yes, I always thought she was more evil than he was, if only because she BELIEVED SHE WAS RIGHT. She wasn't after power because she could take it like Voldemort, she was just absolutely convinced that what she was doing was right, and nothing should stop her.

    Fanatics are always the scariest villains. They're not always the most "evil" characters, but they're usually the ones who strike the most fear in the hearts of others–even if their obsession is something as seemingly benign as building a cathedral (Connie Willis' "To Say Nothing of the Dog.")

    Though, my own to add to this list? Gabriel from Dorothy Dunnett's Lymond Chronicles. Saintly face and reputation, yet doing pure evil all the time. Deliciously terrible.

    Reply

  58. I have to go with the Bard's Iago on this. And while I want to write a lengthy essay on why, I shall curb myself.

    Iago has a plan. Very early on he just wants to ruin Othello, and he goes about it.

    He does it all under the guise of a friend, showing just how deceitful he can be.

    He manipulates others into doing the dirty work for him.

    He succeeds! He ruined the lives in that play. The hero did not overcome him in the end. Desdemona is dead, Othello murdered her, and now knows that he did so without cause. Not only that, Iago leaves an impressive body count in his wake.

    Perhaps most importantly, is that when the whole mix up is revealed, Iago goes quiet on his reasons. he shuts up and stays quiet without elling anyone why he did all this. We're left with an evil and a hate that cannot be explained because the villain is evil enough to know when to shut up (a trait lacking in many a Bond villain).

    Also, he survives. He's walked off the stage alive and whole. WE can all imagine he'll be put to death or imprisoned, but we don't know. He's crafty, and with the right lawyer could get away with it. All the audience is left with is speculation as to this guy's fate, with no proof of one over the other, and that gives him bragging rights to not tell what he did. Others will tell it for him.

    Reply

  61. i wad scared of Pennywise, too until I watched Tim Curry in Clue and then in Oscar. Then 'it' made me laugh. "You've got a dangling participle!"
    My favorite villain of all time is still Alan Rickman as the Sheriff of Nottingham! Of course, I love one liners and he's got quite a few great ones.

    Reply

  62. Where's the Church Lady when you need her?

    I actually think Saruman and the Witch King of the Nazgul are better villains than Sauron.

    The very best villain of all time, though, is the French knight on the castle wall in Monty Python and the Holy Grail. "Your mother was a hamster and your father smelt of elderberries!"

    Reply

  63. Since my goal of becoming published may never happen, thus remaining fiction, I'd have to say… The Literary Agent.

    I kid because I care.

    I'd go with Randall Flagg from The Stand.

    Honorable mention to the serial killer in Blood Work by Michael Connelly (because of his motivation, not the gore).

    Reply

  65. At the risk of sounding immodest, mine, mine, mine! Wait till you meet him. His name is Adair (a one word name!) May 2011.

    Reply

  68. Well MY of course! /joke
    I would have to say there are many great fiction villains. My personal favorites are the ghosts and people of Fatal Frame and Silent Hill. Because not a one of them is truly evil.
    Fatal Frame 1 – Kirie, turned evil by malice when a sacrifical ritual failed because she fell in love
    Fatal Frame 2 – Sae, twisted and made evil by her villages failed sacrifice of her
    Fatal Frame 3 – Reika, tainted by malice and turned evil when a ritual fails and she sees the man she loves killed in front of her
    Silent Hill 1 – Alessa, an innocent girl tortured to birth god
    Silent Hill 2 – The protagonist, James, in a way because he finds out in the end he IS the true antagonist, having smothered his wife
    Silent Hill 3 – Claudia was abused by her father and it made her want to for the birth of God to cleanse the world and usher in Paradise for ALL.
    Silent Hill 4 – Walter was abandoned and twisted by the SH cult doctrine

    Then for movies/books:
    Darth Vader – a good guy as Anakin, seduced to the darkside to save Padme but ends up believing HE was the one who killed her.

    I think the best and scariest of villains are those who you feel weird CALLING villains. They were made into what they were by other people and it really wasn't their fault!

    Reply

  69. I just blogged about this on Monday! 😀 My number one was The Master from Doctor Who. Not sure if that counts since it's a TV show. If not, the greatest villain is Voldemort, hands down.

    Reply

  71. Mrs Danvers from Rebecca…she scared the bejesus out of me and sometimes, sometimes, when I look up and see someone standing at the window I think it's her.

    Reply

  73. Hannibal Lecter, hands down. He is precisely what every human being alive should fear the most: an intelligent vilain. Plus, what's freakier than someone who eats their victim?

    Reply

  76. I have to go with Margot Macomber, from Hemingway's "Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber." Self-absorbed, bullying, she has emasculated her husband. She openly cuckolds him with the safari guide, and the next day, when he gains even a modicum of courage and integrity, she "accidentally" shoots him.

    Reply

  78. It's a tossup between Iago from Othello and Pennywise from Stephen King's It. Iago brought about a lot of destruction and made Othello do things he would have never done, so he was the perfect nemesis. Pennywise scared the @#$% out of the kids in the book and me. He's a villain to remember.

    Reply

  80. I agree completely with Dave @ A Writer's Look on what makes a great villain.

    But I haven't read IT because I'm too scared (which means it probably should win) so I can't comment on that.

    But someone who isn't just going to kill you, yes. There's more fear in living damaged than in simply dying.

    Reply

  82. Across all media, Ukoku from Kazuya Minekura's Saiyuki, hands down.

    If we're talking strictly literary, it's a toss-up between Aaron from Titus Andronicus and Gmork from The Neverending Story.

    Reply

  83. My favourite villain comes from X-Men Comics, so not literature per se, but still fiction.

    Magneto is a well-rounded, three-dimensional villain. A victim of the Holocaust who vowed never to allow similar atrocities to occur to his new people, "mutants". However, in doing so his anger poisoned him and he ended up becoming as bad as those he fought against, engaging in terrorism and murder to achieve his idealistic goals.

    He's a villain that you know has done terrible things, but you can't help but sympathise with his reasons for doing what he does.

    That's how villains should be written IMO. What's that old saying "a protagonist is only as interesting as his antagonist"?

    Reply

  85. Gonna have to throw my hat in with Moriarty, and the Joker. I like the way both compliment and challenge their respective heroes, making almost a symbiosis for the story while being truly compelling and terrifying people.

    Reply

  86. I am with Stu and Bryan… Judge Holden from McCarthy's Blood Meridian, hands down. In no small part because he is only partly fictional, and it is the most horrifying parts that are based in fact.

    Reply

  87. Dr. John Dee from Michael Scott's Flamel series is first

    Achilles from the Bean series of Ender books (Shadow titles) is 2nd

    I am writing a crime novel now with a villian I hope can measure up to those.

    Reply

  88. I saw THE SHINING the other day on TV and I can't think of a villain creepier or more twisted than Jack Torrance…esp at the end when he's charging through the snow with the axe…

    Reply

  89. Wait, Ahab was the villain? I thought the whale was the enemy. I think Ahab is a pretty cool guy. Eh hunts white wales and doesn't afraid of anything.

    For my money there is no greatest villain. It's like asking what a favorite movie is. I mean yeah sure I have an answer I usually give, but is it really my favorite movie when there are so many great ones or am I just saying the first movie that pops into my head? The Cowboys. Ike Clanton's gang have been done to death for a reason. (You said in fiction, not purely fictional)

    Reply

  91. Cthulhu. No question. He's beyond villain. Is there any other literary embodiment of evil that has permeated the popular culture as deeply?

    Reply

  95. Frank CHalmers in Kim Stanley Robinson's Mars Trilogy has always been my favorite. He's a villain until you get to the third book; then he's just a really screwed up guy. I liked how real he was.

    Reply

  96. I'm a big fan of both Acheron Hades and Jack Schitt from Jasper Fforde's The Eyre Affair.

    Acheron is one of those truly evil psychopaths with no plan other than evil. Jack Schitt uses big business/government to accomplish his goals, which always creeped me out.

    Reply

  97. Umbridge. Voldemort knew he was evil, but Umbridge did evil in the name of good.

    It makes me unbelievably sad when I think about how I'll never wait in another midnight line for a new Harry Potter book.

    Reply

  100. Well, Judge Holden is supposedly based on a real person, but the only account of him comes from an autobiography which is pretty widely acknowledged to be unreliable and full of embellishment, so even if he was real, it's hard to tell what the author made up. And then of course McCarthy took that and just made it a million times creepier.

    Reply

  101. Going by who scared me the most, Annie Wilkes, for sure. I've never been so tense reading a book.

    But let's not discount the Vogon leader in Hitchhiker's Guide. Annie Wilkes will cut off your foot, Voldemort will kill you but at least they don't force you to listen to their poetry.

    Reply

  107. There are so many great villains that I don't think I could ever choose just one, but I do want to mention someone who hasn't been named yet (I don't think): "Carrie's" Chris Hargensen. Pure evil.

    Reply

  109. I know he's not the villain one typically thinks of when thinking of Lord of the Rings, but I would have to vote for Gollum. His motives are pretty clear, but it's always interesting to see just how far he'll go to reach his goals. And unlike Sauron, there's more of a sense that Gollum just made some mistakes that led him to become a creepy little frog-like stalker.

    Second choice: Cathy Ames in East of Eden. Oh, how I despised her!

    Lora T.

    Reply

  111. Ooh, from my latest readings, gotta be Mayor Prentiss from the Patrick Ness novels (The Knife of Never Letting Go, The Ask & The Answer, Monsters of Men). The man is clever, manipulative, powerful, scary & gets in your head. Literally.

    Reply

  112. I tend to like creepy cool villains that make your shoulder blades itch just thinking about their evil genious. Saladin in The Forever King is one of my favorites.

    And Janoo Bai from the Far Pavilions is also evil. Considering she's a minor character without much page time, she manages to destroy the lives of most of the other characters in her pursuit of the throne.

    Reply

  113. Voldemort is a dirty little snake! However I'd also like to add someone I'm currently writing… He is a nasty man also known as The Collector. A serial killer of epic and evil porportions.

    Reply

  116. My top three:

    Voldemort is certainly one of the greatest villains. Anyone who kills in order to achieve immortality is as vicious as they come.

    The White Witch from the Chronicles of Narnia always terrified me as a child–a world where it is always winter, but never Christmas is horrifying.

    Dracula. Period. No explanation needed. I still have goosebumps from reading about the Count.

    Reply

  117. One of the ones who freaked me out when I was teaching middle and high school was Mrs. Coulter from His Dark Materials trilogy. She was just plain creepy!

    Reply

  119. I may just be saying this because the fantastic new BBC series is on my mind. But Professor Moriarty. The original Criminal Mastermind!

    Reply

  124. "A great villain to me requires three things:

    1. They threaten you mentally, not physically. A physical threat is a lot easier to deal with, it's tangible, you can respond to it. A mental threat… not so much.

    2. They believe they're right or justified.

    3. They do things their own way."

    You just described my ex-boyfriend.

    I also have to agree about Alec from Tess of the D'Urbervilles, although her family didn't help matters, and Angel was a big baby, so Alec had some help being villainous.

    And Humbert Humbert because you don't think he's a villain for most of Lolita. Any book that makes me feel complicit in the villainy has a damn good villain.

    Reply

  125. @Peter Dudley

    I fart in your general direction.

    Everyone knows that the worst villian of all time is . . . What were we talking about? Damn, I hate getting old.

    Reply

  128. Randall Flagg is pretty high up there, partly because he had a "why not?" approach to evil that made it appealing.

    But for me, it's Arnold Friend from Joyce Carol Oates' Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been? Twenty years after reading it, I still get the chills just thinking about it.

    Reply

  129. Everyone has good reason to nominate the villains they did. Here's a couple that haven't been mentioned:

    Baron Vladimir Harkonen and The Joker.

    Reply

  132. In, I Know This Much Is True by Lamb, the Birdsey twins had an evil step father that I still sometimes think about. Oh sure, he had remorse at a later point in time (reminds me of men I've dated) but it didn't erase the mess that he effected when he was at the top of his game.

    Reply

  135. Snipe was pretty bad, too. He had us all fooled.

    Cathy from East of Eden is a great pick. Been so long since I read that one.

    John Connolly comes up with some pretty scary individuals.

    Darnit, I can't decide.

    Reply

  137. Gotta give some love to the bogeyman. He's unique to me because, in spite of being one of the best known villains of all time, there's no single iconic version of him. Whatever scares you the most, that's what he is.

    Also want to shout out to Magua from Last of the Mohicans. If there's one black list you don't want to be on, it's his.

    Finally, another vote for Judge Holden in Blood Meridian. After I read it for the first time, it felt like evil didn't really exist before him.

    Reply

  139. Oh, and Briony Tallis from Atonement.

    Nothing worse than someone who ruins lives because they think they're doing the right thing.

    Reply

  141. The sorcerer Brandin, from Guy Gavriel Kay's TIGANA.

    Destroyed an entire country and then bespelled the rest of the world so that nobody could remember the country.

    Reply

  143. Voldemort, shmoldemort. I'm going with the others that vote for Umbridge. She is the epitome of what evil looks like. Why? Because true evil looks trustworthy. True evil speaks in a kind, polite voice. True evil is irrational to others but extremely rational to itself. True evil is always trusting to itself. Dolores Umbridge defines the greatest villain in fiction.

    Reply

  146. Quoted from above: "Umbridge. Voldemort knew he was evil, but Umbridge did evil in the name of good.

    It makes me unbelievably sad when I think about how I'll never wait in another midnight line for a new Harry Potter book."

    YES! I have read since I was old enough to speak, but I have never hated a character so much as I hated one Miss Delores Umbridge. And this comment nailed it. She wasn't evil for evil's sake and she wasn't evil because she wanted something for her own. She was evil because she thought what she was doing was RIGHT. That's the scariest kind of evil and the one that gets most people hurt and killed.

    I felt Harry's isolation and frustration when dealing with her. She couldn't be reasoned with and she was in a position of authority, so she couldn't be smacked down.

    Voldemort, as horrific as he was, could almost be understood. At the base of his existence was the will to survive and to defeat death. None of us would go that far, but it's something we can understand (and that in its own right makes him a great villain), but it's that character who's fighting for the establishment – a wrong, evil establishment – and doing it with an air of righteousness that makes my blood boil and scares me as well. Voldemort didn't care if he was wrong. Umbridge didn't even realize she was wrong.

    She makes me angry just thinking about her! But oh how I'd hate to have to deal with her. She is, truly, a formidable foe.

    Reply

  147. He didn't creep me out in the book as much as the TV series, but Arthur Huntingdon from Anne Bronte's 'The Tenant of Wildfell Hall' gave me the creeps. Rupert Graves did such an excellent, playing Arthur as both the cute playboy as well as the drunk abusive husband. One of the creepiest things was how he was the kind of man that you could understand why the MC fell for him.

    Reply

  148. I can't be original on this one, just agree with a bunch of others.

    Umbridge was much worse than Voldemort in many ways, though I think Voldy was worse before he became ALL POWERFUL.

    The Joker in No Man's Land scared the liver out of me. Definitely not your children's comic book kind of guy, and possibly even scarier than in the latest movie (I haven't reread the book since the movie came out, so I can't judge for sure).

    I don't read Stephen King because he's too scary, and based on what I've seen here, I'm right in that assessment and he probably deserves all the kudos he's getting. However, I do like the occasional Dean Koontz, and Junior Cain in From the Corner of His Eye is an awesome bad guy. He is truly evil, and makes me sick reading him, but he also provides comic relief. It's twisted, but it works.p

    Reply

  149. Gilbert Osmond, Portrait of a Lady. Pure evil shellacked with all that civility.
    And from my kids: the other mother (coraline), Voldemort, the jacks (Graveyard Book)

    Reply

  152. I like this question.

    Pride and Prejudice offers both a straightforward bad guy — George Wickham, abductor of young girls, slanderer of Mr. Darcy – and a subtler threat, Darcy’s aunt, Lady Catherine. Wickham merely wants to destroy Darcy’s chance for happiness with Lizzie by ruining her sister and making the whole family socially untouchable. (Just another day at the evil office.)

    Lady Catherine is the living, breathing embodiment of the status-obsession that poisons Darcy’s relationships and makes him fear to do the one heroic thing that would really make him the gentleman he thinks he is.

    Fortunately, Darcy is a good guy at heart who figures out that even 200 years ago, being a class act is less about having the right ancestors and more about whether you treat people decently.

    Reply

  153. Nathan-

    As I was reading through the comments I felt myself agreeing with so many people…and it made me realize something. For me, there is no greatest villain because I've read so many good books that the greatest villain is whatever I'm reading at the time. Hope that makes sense.

    But I can say this. Great villains
    have LAYERS. If all they are is "bad" how can we relate to them? The greatest villains are the ones that could be redeemed I think. The ones where we can see things that remind us of ourselves. To me, that makes them truly creepy.

    A great villain makes me think, makes me see something new about myself. A great villain makes me feel sorry that they are on the wrong path. A great villain makes me want to root for them.

    I guess this doesn't really answer your question Nathen, because I could never pick just one.

    What about YOU? Do you think there is a greatest villain in fiction?

    Reply

  157. I know it's from a movie…but Rasputin from Anastasia is scary.

    Also, Professor Moriarty is quite probably the most intelligent, cunning, coldly logical villain out there.

    But I think, despite all of their villainous characteristics, I have to go with Aunt March from LITTLE WOMEN. She has the uncanny ability to torture, dehumanize, enslave, condemn, and deprive without ever once acting unladylike. Poor Jo.

    Reply

  160. Lady Macbeth and Bill Sykes were both evil manipulators. I loved and pitied Heathcliffe and consider him and Ahab both obsessed but not evil.

    Reply

  162. @D.G. Hudson My first was RAMA at 13 and I've read every Clarke book I could get my hands on since. I love sci-fi, but can't handle horror and I think Childhood's End crossed the line for me. The Alien is an entity that can't be fought in any way and it goes for the children first so you can't even huddle in a closet with your babies until you all get sucked into it together. How scary is that!?!

    I had to stop reading Brave New World halfway through because I was having the same kind of visceral reaction but there's not a specific villain in that book. Fortunately, my high school English teacher accepted my argument for why I couldn't finish it as evidence that I had gotten the point, and gave me an A.

    If Nathan is actually reading this, I would be interested in finding out if other people have had strong physical reactions to books and what those books were. Is that something a publisher would want in a book? Would it help or hinder sales?

    Reply

  166. tjpfau sez:

    Herman Marshall from Robertson's The Ideal Genuine Man.

    He's the only villain I ever read who deep down inside was me.

    My mouth still gets dry thinking about him.

    Reply

  169. The big, evil, power-hungry bad guys are always good for a nightmare. But the truly horrifying evil-dudes that keep me up at night watching over my children are the (sometimes) quiet manipulative-types who seek to gain power by destroying the spirit, the heart, or the innocence of their victims. These types have no conscience.

    Bob Ewel
    Umbridge
    Bill Sykes
    Anyone who preys on children

    I don't have a bigger list because I can't give life to the truly, irredeemably evil by reading very much about them. I should have been born in another time. Or maybe on another planet. 🙂 And this is why I tend to write humor. I'm probably going to have to do something about that though. Maybe therapy . . .

    Reply

  171. @E.A. Provost — I understand where you're coming from regarding books that make you feel almost physically sick — for me it's usually when they describe torture or mutilation — I can't read those either. I don't remember the part you mention about the kids but I read Childhood's End long ago.

    I also read all the RAMA series — that was some setting for a story.
    Also all the followup stories after 2001! (still searching for Dave & Hal)

    Always nice to hear from another sci-fi reader!

    Reply

  173. Darth Vader is the best badass in the history of badasses.

    Period.

    The helmet. So perfect.

    The breathing. So deep and breathy.

    The cape…the way he masterfully swishes it upon exiting the premises.

    The wicked light saber skills.

    The buried vulnerable side…sexy.

    Pure badass through and through.

    Reply

  174. Simple answer- Beelzebub in Bulgokov's Master and Margarita. Aside from rudimentary stimulation of sensationalism, can you comment on this- jrmprojects.blogspot.com ?

    Reply

  177. A few people haven't mentioned yet:

    The Marquise de Merteuil – Dangerous Liaisons

    Becky Sharp – Vanity Fair

    Littlefinger/Varys – A Song of Ice and Fire

    Michael Corleone – The Godfather

    Jack Carter – Get Carter

    Cody Jarrett – White Heat

    Dr Frank N Furter – Rocky Horror Picture Show

    Lee Woo-jin – Oldboy

    Light Yagami – Deathnote

    Mishil – Queen Seon Deok

    Zhuge Liang – Romance of the Three Kingdoms

    Reply

  179. Professor Moriarty broke the mold for the true "Supervillain". After all, Sherlock Holmes described him as the "Napoleon of crime". The first criminal mastermind of prose.

    Reply

  180. For sheer villain psychology no one I've read can match Dostoevsky. There's a prince character in his novel The Insulted and Injured who does absolutely infuriating things to everybody. But then you read the Prince's monologues, and he understands everybody's feelings so well, and sympathizes with them. The Prince knows what it is to be young and passionate, and feel ourselves wronged; but someday we will be grown up realists like him, and see that all his actions were really for the best. Then he goes on explaining — never justifying — and it all sounds so reasonable. Perhaps we only think him a villain because we have our youthful ideals — he admires those ideals — but after all one's youth can not last forever.

    He's enraging. Like any good Dostoevsky character he makes his own disturbing behavior sound all too rational.

    I'd also suggest Daisy from The Great Gatsby. To me she's a more modern kind of evil. Not wicked, just self-absorbed and without any conscience.

    Reply

  182. First, I would place Morgoth over Sauron on the evilness scale. Morgoth actually created (or corrupted) the Orcs.

    The White Witch, yes. Voldemort, definitely. I don't read horror so I can't comment on many that have been mentioned.

    However, someone suggested Heathcliff and that reminded me of another Gothic novel and a romantic hero gone terribly wrong. My vote for worst villain is Nicholas Van Ryn from Dragonwyck. He manages to seduce a young girl into loving him, kills his wife so he can marry her, and then is apparently in the middle of plans to kill her as well before he is… "dealt with." The story creeped me out as all good Gothic novels should, simply because of his malevolence.

    Reply

  183. I agree with a few other readers, and the greatest villain in fiction has got to Ms. Annie Wilkes of Stephen King's Misery.

    Yes, her threat was physical, as in "I'm going to take a sledge hammer to your dearly exposed ankle", but it was more mental/psychological as in "but you don't WHEN I'm going to bring the sledge hammer out or if I even will".

    Her character was plain crazy (which made her unpredictable) but lucid (which made her even more of a threat). The worst aspect of her character was her willingness to play mind games – terrifying!

    Reply

  187. No doubt, forever hungry…. HANNIBAL LECTOR !
    Loved the ending… his stroll through the village, "meeting a friend for dinner".

    Reply

  188. I'd have to go with Voldemort…Sauron is undoubtedly more powerful, but from a character development standpoint, Voldemort seems so real that it's a little spooky…Rowling did a great job of making him human and not just some incarnation of evil.

    Reply

  189. I thought it was interesting that some people mentioned Umbrige, but I'd have to say no to that because she simply misused the office that had been given to her. She had no extraordinary power of her own.

    Truly evil people don't have power simply because they've been handed a position, instead they use their power to seize offices and titles.

    And power is one of the most important aspects of the super villain. My neighbor's Chihuahua is evil, but who cares?

    Reply

  191. Edward Cullen.

    Okay, bear with me here: I know he's supposed to be the romantic lead. However, even setting the gag factor aside, he has tremendous potential as a villain.

    1) He's powerful. He's fast, strong, and virtually indestructible.

    2) He has similarly strong allies. Edward can read minds – the people he calls family can see the future, etc. Dangerous combination.

    3) Others believe in him. While this could be the trait of a true romantic hero, in Twilight it comes off as beyond creepy. Okay, the high school students are intimidated, but that's about it. Meanwhile, Bella is willing to go to the end of the earth for Edward, despite his actions being controlling and sometimes abusive. She's a sidekick if ever there was one. He's a successful villain because he isn't recognised as such.

    Think about the havoc he could wreak if he ever decided to embrace his unlife as a vampire. So much untapped potential!

    Reply

  192. Erik from Gaston Leroux's The Phantom of the Opera. It's hard to find a villain who's more loved, or who has had a longer life than Erik.

    Reply

  194. Javert from Les Miserables is an evil, also tragic, villain. I also fear Hyde, from Jekyll and Hyde, because he is the villain in each of us.
    As I child I feared Hook from Peter Pan the most–he would slay the lost boys and his own pirates without batting an eye.

    Reply

  196. Oh, I love these! My brother and I have just been emailing back and forth "What are your top three ________ (gunfights, sci-fi movies, one-liners, etc.)

    My vote has to go to Moriarty. We don't get to know him very well, but anyone that can give Sherlock Holmes a run for his money is pretty awesome.

    Also whoever said Edward Cullen deserves a cookie — that sick bloodsucker has probably psychologically damaged more females than anyone else in the world.

    Reply

  197. Reading all of these comments has helped me with my writing.

    I have a villain who starts off as a good guy, but changes in the end.

    Now I know that in the beginning, he'll be called by both of his names, but in the end, he'll just be called by his first name to keep with the whole "one name is scarier" theme.

    Thanks, guys.

    Reply

  199. I want to agree with the choice of Professor Umbridge, but I'm not sure she's an all-time villain.

    Probably have to say Hannibal Lecter, but I controversially consider all texts after 'Hannibal' (and even parts of 'Hannibal') to be non-canon fanfiction so I am just talking about Lecter of Red Dragon and Silence of the Lambs 🙂

    Reply

  200. I would have to agree Dolores Umbridge from Harry Potter was the villain that got under my skin the most. But it wasn't fear, it was Hate.

    'It' from a wrinkle in time definitely scared me though. And the aliens from Signs. All they wanted was to kill, and they were sneaky which is just scary!

    Reply

  202. Nurse Ratched, for sure…and Mama Elena in "Like Water for Chocolate" — two ladies who simply oozed villainy.

    Reply

  204. This has been an interesting thread, but also rather disturbing.

    I hope next week's You Tell Me will be about the greatest bunny rabbit in fiction.

    Or teddy bear. I'm not picky.

    Reply

  205. My vote is for Prof. Moriarty. His presence and impact were felt well beyond the relatively few original stories in which he was mentioned.

    Reply

  206. Wow! Lots of great suggestions.

    My first thought was Ranulf of Chester from Edith Partiger's Heaven Tree Trilogy. In addition to being powerful, unscrupulously ambitious and a manipulator of men, he was a real historical figure. King Stephen didn't have a chance!

    Voldemort, Umbrige, forget them. I'll go for Snape. He had me squirming in my chair, and the fact that you never knew what side he was really on, could sympathize with his abused childhood and yet still consider him a little creep who deserved it, just added to the mix. Even more to Rowling's credit,she had me hoping he'd turn out ok in the end.

    But, for me, the greatest villan of all time is one I recently came across: Keith Allen playing the Sheriff of Nottingham in the new Jonas Armstrong BBC Robin Hood series (well, not that new, it's been going for 3 years. Last year was its last season.) Every time he'd take a canary out it cage and crush it in his hands, every time he'd get someone's hopes up and then say,"Wrong," I'd shutter. He's witty (in a black humor way), sadistic and totally socialpathic. And that gold tooth he'd take in and out! Gets my vote.

    Reply

  208. ooo, The minute I saw the question my choice was Iago. There is just something about a "friend" that stabs you in the back that screams evil. But in the spirit of being original what about Beowulf in the novel Grendel? Think about that one.

    Reply

  209. Flagg.

    Voldemort was great, but didn't pack the fear for me.

    Talking movies, pinhead.

    Most of the books I read lately the heroes are their own worst enemy.

    Reply

  211. My vote goes to Livia the poisoner in Robert Graves' I, Claudius. At the end of her life, she is such a diminished, weakened character who still begs Claudius, the boy she hated and mocked as he grew up, to do right by her after she dies. She has murdered and betrayed nearly everyone who comes into her view. Evil woman. Evil: the progenitor of every evil villainess to follow, from Mrs. Johnny Iselin in The Manchurian Candidate to the Livia Soprano who plots to have her mobster son murdered.

    Reply

  213. My favorite is Cruella de Vil from The Hundred and One Dalmations from Dodie Smith. A coat made from puppies? No way!

    In history, who could ever forget Adolf Hitler and Adolf Eichmann and the rest of the horrid Nazi's. Now that's pure evil and not fiction.

    Reply

  215. Thank you for this topic, Nathan. Enjoyed reading the comments.

    I would say Heathcliff from Wuthering Heights (Could never understand why Cathy preferred him over good, gentle Edgar), Dolores Umbridge who evokes so much more hatred than even Voldemort, Humbert from Lolita (Gross), Claude Frollo and the Thénardier couple, Becky Sharp, Uriah Heep, It from a Wrinkle in Time (shudder), the Murdstones and many of the villains from Dickens and Shakespeare…Hate 'em all.

    Reply

  217. I'd have to say that the Man in Black is the greatest villain; the one from The Gunslinger, by Stephen King. He seemed to be one step ahead of Roland, and anyone who can outmaneuver Roland deserves some props.

    Reply

  218. Sauron from Lord of the Rings gets my vote. First of all, you never saw him. He was this evil entity with pure hatred in his nonexistent heart. That eye, always searching gives me the creeps.

    I do have to agree with many posts voting for King's Pennywise. I cannot look at clowns because of him.

    One more – the whole book Pet Cemetary – read the last line and you'll understand pure horror.

    Reply

  219. Definetly Iago.Described as a "motiveless malignity" by Samuel Taylor Coleridge, he enjoys others suffering for the pure sadistic relish.
    Non-fiction must fall to Judas with Brutus a distant second.
    Cowboy Surfer

    Reply

  221. Antoine Leng Pendergast from Preston and Child's "Cabinet of Curiosities."

    A man who tortured dozens of people to discover the secret of immortality so he could live long enough to exterminate human life.

    Reply

  223. Strange but my choices for greatest villain are taken from my favourite childhood authors:

    -C.S. Lewis' Jadis, the White Witch from his Chronicles of Narnia series

    -the always formidable Miss Agatha Trunchbull from Matilda by Roald Dahl.

    Reply

  224. So many choices…

    I have to admit to liking Disney villains. They may not always have the most complex characters, but they tend to be very stylish, which I like in a villain. There's something about a swishing cloak, and they can be more stylish and interesting than the heroes. I always loved Maleficent (and loathed all the fairies except Merryweather. The green one, Fauna, was such an annoying drip!)

    Mrs Danvers: yes, exceptionally creepy, though I wonder if Rebecca herself doesn't deserve a mention, even though she never appears in person.

    From TV: Mr Morden from Babylon 5. Makes my skin crawl. The Shadow themselves are deeply scary, but he's the real villain.

    If we're going for Jasper Fforde, the worst of the Hades siblings has to be Aornis. She gets in your head and messes with it!

    Got to agree with whoever said Mr Croup and Mr Vandemar. They are excellent villains. Also with all the votes for the White Witch and Umbridge.

    Is Lady Macbeth a villain, or also a tragic hero(ine)? In the end, she can't be as heartless as she wanted to be – what she's done affects her deeply and leads to her taking her own life. But then she wanted to be a cold-blooded murderer. Discuss…

    Macavity the Mystery Cat. A classic villainous mastermind.

    Aphrodite in Euripides' Hippolytus. The Greek gods make very good villains. Look up Apollo and see how many people he destroyed without caring (cf Cassandra).

    I could be at this all day, but had better stop now.

    Reply

  225. I have to agree with all of these suggestions. Super creepy villains here.

    On the Voldemort / Umbridge front, yes. Definitely evil incarnate, both of them. But I don't feel like Bellatrix Lestrange is getting her props. Come on, she killed her own cousin and laughed about it! Not to mention she spends the entire series wreaking havoc on the lives of Harry and his friends just to earn the love of someone who will never love anyone but himself. How messed up is that?

    Also, Warren Hoyt from Tess Gerritsen's The Surgeon and The Apprentice.
    The scariest thing about him is that there are real people out there who might do those kinds of things. I had to get my blood taken for a test a few days after finishing these books (I finished both of them in two days) and was seriously freaked out about where that part of me was going and who might get their hands on it… I think villains that mess with your mind like that are the best ones.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *